Tuckered out

Below are three photos that show different levels of editing. This first one has been edited the most. The last one is a straight-out-of-the-camera shot, and the middle one is in-between. Can you tell the difference in each? With the middle one, I used an unsharp mask in Photoshop to sharpen the image (counterintuitive, I know, but that's how PS rolls with its masking features). I also used the Pioneer Woman action for brightening eyes. I like the second photo better than the first, mostly for the sharpness. But it seems like I somehow lost some of the color saturation after making those edits, even though I didn't touch the saturation! So for the photo immediately below, I increased the saturation a little bit. Which of the three do you prefer?